The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)
From: Effects of balance transfer offers on consumer short-term finance: evidence from credit card data
Variables | Take-up rate | Take-up rate | Take-up rate | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Group (A): PD = 6, fee > 0 | Group (B): PD = 12 | Group (C): PD = 6, fee = 0 | ||||
Coef. | SE | Coef. | SE | Coef. | SE | |
FFL | −1.06e−02 | 3.53e−03*** | −5.71e−02 | 0.01*** | −4.01e−02 | 4.77e−03*** |
PR | −1.54e−02 | 1.91e03*** | −2.45e−02 | 0.01*** | −2.42e−02 | 3.53e−03*** |
BT fee | −3.29e−04 | 2.41e−04 | −7.75e−04 | 4.3e−04* | Omitted | |
PB balance | 1.18e−06 | 1.66e−06 | 1.57e−06 | 3.82e−06 | 4.28e−06 | 2.81e−06 |
Finance charge | 4.87e−04 | 1.33e−04*** | −1.86e−04 | 3.06e−04 | 3.34e−04 | 2.22e−04 |
Fee | −5.18e−04 | 1.78e−04*** | −2.79e−03 | 4.17e−04*** | −3.71e−03 | 3.01e−04*** |
Spending | −1.38e−05 | 7.82e−06* | −2.61e−05 | 1.52e−05* | −1.69e−05 | 1.22e−05 |
Payment | 1.05e−05 | 3.19e−06*** | 2.63e−05 | 7.27e−06*** | 1.8e−05 | 5.33e−06*** |
Cash spend | 3.88e−05 | 3.57e−04 | 2.69e−04 | 8.63e−05*** | 1.06e−04 | 4.42e−05*** |
CCC # | 4.28e−05 | 6.45e−03 | −6.67e−03 | 0.01 | 3.23e−03 | 0.01 |
EFX # | −6.33e−04 | 2.87e−04*** | 3.73e−04 | 6.39e−04 | 1.37e−03 | 4.7e−04*** |
EFX limit | −1.02e−07 | 3.58e−08*** | 9.04e−08 | 8.31e−08 | 1.12e−07 | 6.07e−08* |
CCC limit | −1.57e−06 | 5.20e−07*** | −4.07e−08 | 1.15e−06 | −2.67e−06 | 8.67e−07*** |
Behavior score | 4.67e−05 | 1.48e−05*** | −7.22e−05 | 3.12e−05* | −2e−05 | 2.43e−05 |
FICO score | −2.49e−04 | 4.56e−05*** | −2.98e−04 | 1.02e−04*** | −1.5e−04 | 7.54e−05*** |
CCC U. ratio | −0.04 | 6.73e−03*** | −0.07 | 0.02*** | −0.10 | 0.01*** |
EFX U. ratio | 0.06 | 0.13*** | 0.10 | 0.03*** | 0.09 | 0.02*** |
Cons | 0.41 | 0.05*** | 0.76 | 0.10*** | 0.54 | 0.07*** |