Skip to main content

The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)

Table 6 Regression results for three groups

From: Effects of balance transfer offers on consumer short-term finance: evidence from credit card data

 

Total payment

Total spending

ΔCCC Bal.

ΔEFX Bal.

ΔPB Bal.

Coef.

SE

Coef.

SE

Coef.

SE

Coef.

SE

Coef.

SE

PD = 6, fee > 0

          

 FFL

88.79

47.01*

0.69

17.25

−145.9

53.12***

−130.28

187.19

−15.03

15.17

 PR

−45.53

25.52***

−0.88

9.36

87.61

28.84***

60.29

101.64

3.55

8.24

 PB balance

0.2

0.02***

0.11

8.01e−3***

−0.24

0.02***

−0.08

0.08

−0.2

7.12e−3***

 Finance charge

−37.72

1.78***

−1.66

0.65***

12.72

2.01***

3.04

7.08

4.62

0.57***

 Fee

64.13

2.35***

−2.7

0.86***

−51.44

2.66***

−19.72

9.40***

0.09

0.76

 Spending

4.07

0.10***

3.12

0.03***

0.3

0.11***

1.52

0.41

−0.35

0.03***

 Payment

−0.23

0.04***

0.23

0.02

0.12

0.04***

−0.32

0.16*

0.27

0.01***

 Cash spend

3.62

0.47***

−0.19

0.17

2.27

0.53***

8.53

1.89***

−1.02

0.15***

 CCC #

−698.67

85.71***

−15.68

31.45

−543.76

96.99***

1769.15

341.76***

−100.7

27.71***

 EFX #

14.66

3.81***

−7.93

1.40***

−18.74

4.31***

−52.19

15.18***

−7.75

1.23***

 EFX limit

0.002

4.77e−4***

−0.002

1.75e−4***

0.003

5.39e−4***

0.01

1.89e−3***

−0.001

1.54e−4***

 CCC limit

0.31

6.91e−3***

0.02

2.54e−3***

0.1

7.83e−3***

0.16

0.03***

0.005

2.23e−3***

 Behavior score

−0.62

0.19

0.12

0.07*

0.69

0.22***

−1.32

0.78*

0.013

0.06

 FICO score

−0.06

0.61***

0.23

0.22

−7.45

0.68***

−12.54

2.41***

−0.58

0.19***

 CCC U. ratio

2820.6

89.62***

−287.95

32.89***

−6470.5

101.25***

261.16

356.79

−491.34

28.93***

 EFX U. ratio

705.87

172.25***

24.97

63.21

3300.34

194.75***

−12,203.6

686.23***

326.42

55.64***

 Cons

−894.48

641.55

63.41

235.45

8430.6

724.61***

12,136.4

2553.26***

896.49

207.02***

PD = 12

          

 FFL

95.7

97.01

−76

39.15*

−57.63

114.35

315.04

406.52

−55.56

33.75

 PR

−76.14

80.33

80.74

32.42***

−26.8

94.68

−327.62

336.58

57.03

27.94***

 PB balance

0.28

0.04***

0.06

0.01***

−0.28

0.04***

0.03

0.15

−0.28

0.01***

 Finance charge

−36.53

2.89***

−0.83

1.17

9.89

3.42***

−25.67

12.15***

8.03

1.01***

 Fee

60.93

3.95***

−1.58

1.59

−61.55

4.66***

−12.31

16.57

1.73

1.37

 Spending

4.1

0.14***

3.65

0.06***

0.13

0.16

1.85

0.60***

−0.33

0.05***

 Payment

−0.32

0.07***

0.23

0.03***

0.38

0.08***

−0.49

0.28*

0.3

0.02***

 Cash spend

3.31

0.81***

0.07

55.76

2.46

0.96***

0.44

3.43

−0.02

0.28

 CCC #

−887.05

138.17***

−66.53

2.45

−540.83

163.17***

1492.69

580.07***

−6.83

48.15

 EFX #

12.72

6.07***

−8.29

3.18e−4***

−33.69

7.14***

−20.41

25.40

−9.02

2.11***

 EFX limit

0.003

7.89e−4***

−0.001

4.4e−3***

0.006

9.29e−4***

1.58e−3

3.33e−3

−0.001

2.74e−4***

 CCC limit

0.29

0.01***

0.01

0.12***

0.08

0.01***

0.07

0.04

−0.009

3.8e−3***

 Behavior score

−0.7

0.29***

−0.09

0.39

0.22

0.34

−3.86

1.23***

−0.003

0.10

 FICO score

−0.54

0.96

1.04

58.89***

−5.59

1.14***

−7.12

4.06*

0.41

0.34

 CCC U. ratio

2703.43

145.92***

−265.58

−4.51***

−6451.12

172.06***

793.52

611.69

−553.7

50.78***

 EFX U. ratio

633.96

282.43***

153.82

113.99

3950.92

333.01***

−10,809.1

1183.84***

443.67

98.28***

 Cons

−278.12

925.53

8.56

373.54

7007.85

1091.57***

7998.88

3880.50***

333.21

322.16

PD = 6, fee = 0

          

 FFL

64.47

48.86

7.5

19.01

−101.83

54.32*

124.68

189.93

−21.63

15.08

 PR

−140.44

36.20***

4.91

14.09

22.05

40.25

−182.03

140.73

12.64

11.17

 PB balance

0.16

0.03***

0.07

0.01***

−0.27

0.03***

−0.05

0.11

−0.21

8.89e−3***

 Finance charge

−38.44

2.27***

0.26

0.88

18.64

2.52***

18.45

8.83***

4.93

0.70***

 Fee

61.9

3.08***

−1.47

1.19

−55.71

3.42***

−0.23

11.98

1.1

0.95

 Spending

4.27

0.12***

3.49

0.04***

−0.32

0.13***

0.91

0.48*

−0.25

0.03***

 Payment

−0.1

0.05*

0.21

0.02***

0.38

0.06***

−0.1

0.21

0.24

0.02***

 Cash spend

1.58

0.45***

0.04

0.17

2.47

0.50***

2.78

1.76

−0.26

0.14*

 CCC #

−797.83

109.85***

−40.62

42.76

−219.16

122.47*

1709.87

428.22***

−43.61

34.01

 EFX #

12.72

4.82***

−8.29

1.87***

−33.69

5.35***

−20.41

18.73

−9

1.48***

 EFX limit

10.16

6.21e−4***

−7.83

2.42e−4***

−32.94

6.91e−4***

−41.99

2.41e−3***

−4.35

1.92e−4***

 CCC limit

0.31

8.88e−3***

0.01

3.46e−3***

0.07

9.88e−3***

0.04

0.03

0.001

2.74e−3

 Behavior score

−0.85

0.25***

−0.08

0.10

0.71

0.27***

−1.45

0.96

−0.06

0.08

 FICO score

0.62

0.77

0.97

0.30***

−6.8

0.85***

−8.42

3.00***

−0.15

0.24

 CCC U. ratio

2715.78

113.86***

−236.64

44.32***

−6662.5

126.61***

−604.9

442.70

430.19

35.15***

 EFX U. ratio

1191.27

224.55***

147.73

87.41*

3658.87

249.80***

−11,667.4

873.40***

409.52

69.36***

 Cons

−891.97

685.38

−390.55

266.80

7433.67

762.64***

9412.06

2666.51***

530.25

211.76***

  1. The table reports the marginal effects of characteristics to five dependent variables in the three groups. The standard ΔCCC Bal, ΔEFX Bal., and ΔPB Bal. stand for the change of balance in RBS bank, the change of balance in Equifax bureau, and the changed protected balance
  2. *, *** Coefficients are significant at the level of 10 and 5%