Skip to main content

The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)

Table 3 Comparison between the “conventional” environmental efficiency indicator (CEEI) and the “DEA-based” environmental efficiency indicator (DEEI)

From: Accounting for resource accumulation in Japanese prefectures: an environmental efficiency analysis

Region Prefecture 1992 2008
CEEI Rank DEEI Rank CEEI Rank DEEI Rank
Hokkaido Hokkaido 0.457 28 0.303 44 0.382 39 0.474 46
Tohoku Aomori 0.372 36 0.302 43 0.402 36 0.395 45
Iwate 0.450 30 0.257 40 0.517 31 0.297 39
Miyagi 0.531 21 0.304 45 0.526 29 0.312 40
Akita 0.562 19 0 1 0.631 19 0 1
Yamagata 0.569 13 0.159 32 0.706 11 0.132 23
Fukushima 0.568 15 0.279 42 0.669 15 0.099 15
Kanto Ibaraki 0.345 39 0.273 41 0.404 35 0.180 28
Tochigi 0.628 8 0.176 35 0.711 10 0.093 14
Gunma 0.648 6 0.199 37 0.666 16 0.237 35
Saitama 0.609 9 0.196 36 0.635 17 0.327 43
Chiba 0.313 40 0.129 25 0.326 41 0.315 41
Tokyo 1.341 1 0 1 1.332 1 0 1
Kanagawa 0.562 18 0.098 19 0.579 24 0.219 31
Chubu Niigata 0.498 26 0.365 46 0.538 28 0.318 42
Toyama 0.380 34 0.116 23 0.557 25 0.115 17
Ishikawa 0.584 11 0.107 21 0.733 7 0.117 18
Fukui 0.509 24 0.061 12 0.606 20 0.009 10
Yamanashi 0.737 5 0 1 0.809 4 0 1
Nagano 0.648 7 0.253 39 0.782 5 0.176 27
Gifu 0.536 20 0.064 14 0.596 22 0.287 38
Shizuoka 0.516 23 0.240 38 0.723 8 0.091 13
Aichi 0.478 27 0.114 22 0.557 26 0.113 16
Kinki Mie 0.354 38 0.154 31 0.523 30 0 1
Shiga 0.605 10 0 1 0.776 6 0 1
Kyoto 0.863 2 0 1 0.946 2 0.081 12
Osaka 0.842 3 0 1 0.881 3 0.191 29
Hyogo 0.409 33 0.099 20 0.398 38 0.251 36
Nara 0.786 4 0 1 0.699 12 0 1
Wakayama 0.308 41 0.150 30 0.320 42 0.226 32
Chugoku Tottori 0.508 25 0 1 0.510 32 0 1
Shimane 0.452 29 0.094 18 0.474 33 0.126 19
Okayama 0.199 45 0.126 24 0.193 46 0.252 37
Hiroshima 0.254 43 0.141 28 0.283 43 0.131 21
Yamaguchi 0.199 44 0.064 13 0.198 45 0.126 20
Shikoku Tokushima 0.417 32 0 1 0.590 23 0.008 9
Kagawa 0.520 22 0.007 11 0.597 21 0.165 25
Ehime 0.297 42 0.144 29 0.352 40 0.228 33
Kochi 0.369 37 0 1 0.401 37 0.056 11
Kyushu Fukuoka 0.378 35 0.078 16 0.472 34 0.358 44
Saga 0.566 16 0.077 15 0.720 9 0 1
Nagasaki 0.582 12 0.084 17 0.688 14 0.135 24
Kumamoto 0.568 14 0.168 33 0.635 18 0.231 34
Oita 0.172 46 0.138 26 0.227 44 0.132 22
Miyazaki 0.432 31 0.140 27 0.539 27 0.207 30
Kagoshima 0.566 17 0.172 34 0.694 13 0.174 26
  Mean 0.511   0.127   0.576   0.161