Skip to main content

The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)

Table 3 Mean TFEEs and TGR by region in Japan (1996–2008)

From: A meta-stochastic frontier analysis for energy efficiency of regions in Japan

Region Group TFEE TGR Metafrontier TFEE
Group 1 (metropolitan)
 Kumamoto 0.952 (1) 0.899 (2) 0.855 (2)
 Kyoto 0.939 (2) 0.987 (1) 0.927 (1)
 Saitama 0.934 (3) 0.874 (4) 0.815 (3)
 Hokkaido 0.932 (4) 0.540 (16) 0.501 (9)
 Tokyo 0.898 (5) 0.898 (3) 0.806 (4)
 Niigata 0.884 (6) 0.632 (15) 0.554 (8)
 Miyagi 0.881 (7) 0.802 (5) 0.705 (5)
 Osaka 0.838 (8) 0.726 (11) 0.603 (7)
 Shizuoka 0.821 (9) 0.765 (7) 0.624 (6)
 Aichi 0.738 (10) 0.653 (14) 0.477 (11)
 Fukuoka 0.629 (11) 0.782 (6) 0.488 (10)
 Hyogo 0.535 (12) 0.675 (13) 0.356 (13)
 Kanagawa 0.477 (13) 0.763 (8) 0.362 (12)
 Hiroshima 0.378 (14) 0.748 (9) 0.282 (14)
 Chiba 0.208 (15) 0.746 (10) 0.155 (15)
 Okayama 0.168 (16) 0.724 (12) 0.120 (16)
 Group 1 mean 0.701   0.763   0.539  
Group 2 (rural)
 Ishikawa 0.963 (1) 0.950 (12) 0.915 (2)
 Yamagata 0.960 (2) 0.933 (16) 0.896 (5)
 Shimane 0.959 (3) 0.701 (30) 0.673 (16)
 Okinawa 0.957 (4) 0.919 (18) 0.880 (6)
 Nagano 0.945 (5) 0.979 (4) 0.925 (1)
 Nagasaki 0.943 (6) 0.962 (10) 0.907 (3)
 Nara 0.924 (7) 0.973 (6) 0.899 (4)
 Saga 0.915 (8) 0.789 (28) 0.725 (13)
 Yamanashi 0.894 (9) 0.894 (22) 0.799 (7)
 Akita 0.853 (10) 0.904 (20) 0.772 (9)
 Gumma 0.803 (11) 0.975 (5) 0.783 (8)
 Tochigi 0.793 (12) 0.858 (24) 0.680 (15)
 Fukushima 0.786 (13) 0.967 (8) 0.760 (10)
 Iwate 0.763 (14) 0.985 (3) 0.751 (11)
 Kagoshima 0.753 (15) 0.997 (1) 0.751 (12)
 Tottori 0.740 (16) 0.731 (29) 0.543 (20)
 Gifu 0.729 (17) 0.989 (2) 0.721 (14)
 Fukui 0.699 (18) 0.827 (27) 0.581 (18)
 Miyazaki 0.657 (19) 0.903 (21) 0.592 (17)
 Kochi 0.649 (20) 0.648 (31) 0.420 (25)
 Shiga 0.644 (21) 0.891 (23) 0.572 (19)
 Tokushima 0.577 (22) 0.842 (25) 0.486 (22)
 Aomori 0.521 (23) 0.962 (9) 0.502 (21)
 Toyama 0.509 (24) 0.925 (17) 0.472 (23)
 Kagawa 0.458 (25) 0.937 (15) 0.429 (24)
 Ehime 0.341 (26) 0.967 (7) 0.330 (26)
 Wakayama 0.332 (27) 0.833 (26) 0.277 (27)
 Mie 0.249 (28) 0.910 (19) 0.226 (29)
 Ibaraki 0.248 (29) 0.938 (14) 0.233 (28)
 Yamaguchi 0.136 (30) 0.953 (11) 0.129 (30)
 Oita 0.117 (31) 0.943 (13) 0.110 (31)
 Group 2 mean 0.671   0.903   0.605  
Total mean 0.681   0.855   0.582