Skip to main content

The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)

Table 10 Statistics of the mean absolute percentage differences (MAPEs) between the estimated and observed type I output multipliers from alternative approaches

From: A new approach to modelling the input–output structure of regional economies using non-survey methods

  MCE FLQ+ FLQ0.3 GRAS GRAS+ AFLQ AFLQ+ SLQ
Gyeonggi 11.408 1.913 3.355 16.875 5.682 0.605 1.748 4.940
Seoul 15.252 1.947 0.707 2023.701 8.554 0.108 1.145 2.320
N Gyeongsang 14.979 2.120 3.155 8.967 9.253 0.415 2.235 7.788
S Gyeongsang 1.697 4.489 4.293 9.531 8.050 3.039 2.799 5.232
Ulsan 23.051 3.868 0.186 315.443 10.203 2.905 3.440 3.860
South Jeolla 15.573 1.184 3.263 2.784 9.754 8.091 11.756 9.666
S Chungcheong 0.327 2.077 0.463 3.149 6.177 7.046 2.575 17.014
Incheon 22.071 2.638 2.415 284.593 4.704 1.882 2.557 13.515
Busan 12.517 2.825 2.825 261.020 5.314 3.191 2.729 2.436
N Chungcheong 4.436 4.190 4.190 12.482 6.827 0.247 0.247 12.200
Daegu 13.808 3.204 4.513 199.788 5.636 3.979 2.922 9.937
North Jeolla 6.728 2.046 2.333 4.315 4.871 5.298 8.479 14.849
Gangwon 5.919 6.580 7.671 377.345 7.859 1.692 2.505 2.589
Gwangju 11.166 4.110 3.730 503.281 4.803 4.924 4.097 3.717
Daejeon 18.257 2.850 1.493 575.148 2.762 4.563 2.612 13.339
Jeju 7.077 1.933 5.860 2.827 5.187 7.743 17.545 13.453
Mean 11.517 2.998 3.153 287.578 6.602 3.483 4.337 8.553
Weighted mean 12.456 2.589 2.548 461.489 7.201 2.392 3.041 6.822
V 6.540 1.321 1.911 486.558 2.056 2.559 4.367 4.881
  1. FLQ0.3 denotes the FLQ with a fixed δ = 0.3