The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)
Table 11 Statistics of the mean percentage differences (MPEs) between the estimated and observed type I output multipliers from alternative approaches
MCE | FLQ+ | FLQ0.3 | GRAS | GRAS+ | AFLQ | AFLQ+ | SLQ | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gyeonggi | 11.408 | − 1.913 | 3.355 | − 16.875 | − 5.682 | − 0.605 | − 1.748 | 4.940 |
Seoul | 15.252 | − 1.947 | − 0.707 | − 2023.701 | − 8.554 | − 0.108 | − 1.145 | − 2.320 |
N Gyeongsang | 14.979 | − 2.120 | − 3.155 | − 8.967 | − 9.253 | 0.415 | 2.235 | 7.788 |
S Gyeongsang | 1.697 | − 4.489 | − 4.293 | − 9.531 | − 8.050 | − 3.039 | − 2.799 | 5.232 |
Ulsan | 23.051 | − 3.868 | − 0.186 | − 315.443 | − 10.203 | − 2.905 | − 3.440 | 3.860 |
South Jeolla | 15.573 | − 1.184 | − 3.263 | 2.784 | − 9.754 | 8.091 | 11.756 | 9.666 |
S Chungcheong | 0.327 | − 2.077 | 0.463 | 3.149 | − 6.177 | 7.046 | 2.575 | 17.014 |
Incheon | 22.071 | − 2.638 | 2.415 | − 284.593 | − 4.704 | − 1.882 | − 2.557 | 13.515 |
Busan | 12.517 | − 2.825 | − 2.825 | − 261.020 | − 5.314 | − 3.191 | − 2.729 | 2.436 |
N Chungcheong | − 4.436 | − 4.190 | − 4.190 | − 12.482 | − 6.827 | 0.247 | 0.247 | 12.200 |
Daegu | 13.808 | − 3.204 | − 4.513 | − 199.788 | − 5.636 | − 3.979 | − 2.922 | 9.937 |
North Jeolla | − 6.728 | − 2.046 | − 2.333 | − 4.315 | − 4.871 | 5.298 | 8.479 | 14.849 |
Gangwon | 5.919 | − 6.580 | − 7.671 | 377.345 | − 7.859 | − 1.692 | − 2.505 | 2.589 |
Gwangju | 11.166 | − 4.110 | − 3.730 | − 503.281 | − 4.803 | − 4.924 | − 4.097 | 3.717 |
Daejeon | 18.257 | − 2.850 | − 1.493 | − 575.148 | − 2.762 | − 4.563 | − 2.612 | 13.339 |
Jeju | − 7.077 | − 1.933 | − 5.860 | 2.827 | − 5.187 | 7.743 | 17.545 | 13.453 |
Mean | 9.237 | − 2.998 | − 2.374 | − 239.315 | − 6.602 | 0.122 | 1.018 | 8.263 |
Weighted mean | 11.736 | − 2.589 | − 0.876 | − 444.087 | − 7.201 | 0.026 | − 0.095 | 5.978 |
V | 9.492 | − 1.321 | − 2.821 | − 512.024 | − 2.056 | 4.321 | 6.070 | 5.357 |