The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)
From: Does innovative capacity affect the deindustrialization process? A panel data analysis
Regressors | Model 1 | Model 2 | Model 3 | Model 4 | Model 5 | Model 6 | Model 7 | Model 8 | Model 9 | Model 10 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BASELINE | R&D | RESEARCHERS | TECHNICIANS | ARTICLE | PATENTS | TRADEMARK | INCENG | INDOUT | INES | |
LN EMPSHARE(-1) | 0.869828*** | 0.678002*** | 0.856861*** | 0.721469*** | 0.778751*** | 0.810980*** | 0.844851*** | 0.804786*** | 0.705562*** | 0.633975*** |
(0.013829) | (0.015378) | (0.033870) | (0.024906) | (0.016856) | (0.018288) | (0.030733) | (0.023125) | (0.039546) | (0.029644) | |
LN Y | 0.117183** | 1.168891*** | 0.518018* | 1.427659*** | 0.473954*** | 0.376770*** | 0.169181*** | 0.689775*** | 0.601621*** | 1.049838*** |
(0.055889) | (0.090563) | (0.269793) | (0.213328) | (0.083156) | (0.082948) | (0.064403) | (0.248777) | (0.150898) | (0.125336) | |
(LN Y)2 | − 0.008562*** | − 0.066846*** | − 0.031274** | − 0.078420*** | − 0.032316*** | − 0.024336*** | − 0.012537*** | − 0.039248*** | − 0.036843*** | − 0.063656*** |
(0.003056) | (0.004929) | (0.014318) | (0.010656) | (0.004670) | (0.004394) | (0.003860) | (0.013111) | (0.008459) | (0.007124) | |
FIXCAP | 0.001076*** | 0.007374*** | 0.005642*** | 0.005530*** | 0.001823*** | 0.004149*** | 0.001997** | 0.007396*** | 0.006614*** | 0.004777*** |
(0.000399) | (0.000855) | (0.000966) | (0.000740) | (0.0003390 | (0.000296) | (0.000780) | (0.001123) | (0.000963) | (0.000969) | |
TRADEBAL | 0.000334** | 0.001822*** | 0.000585 | 0.001049*** | 0.001158*** | 0.000516** | 0.000955* | 0.002814*** | 0.001093** | 0.001821*** |
(0.000151) | (0.000490) | (0.000601) | (0.000297) | (0.000209) | (0.000239) | (0.000571) | (0.000717) | (0.000513) | (0.000651) | |
RIR | − 0.001737*** | − 0.000529** | − 0.003029*** | − 0.002873*** | − 0.001207*** | − 0.001734*** | − 0.001101*** | − 0.001625*** | − 0.000666* | − 0.000431* |
(0.000148) | (0.000251) | (0.000606) | (0.000433) | (0.000155) | (0.000219) | (0.000194) | (0.000460) | (0.000363) | (0.000246) | |
RER | 0.000300*** | 0.000219* | 0.000424*** | 0.000588*** | 0.000861*** | 0.000344*** | 0.000248** | 0.000451*** | 0.000299*** | 0.000752*** |
(5.84E−05) | (0.000116) | (0.000100) | (0.000155) | (0.000127) | (5.35E−05) | (0.000110) | (8.51E−05) | (0.000110) | (0.000145) | |
INNOV*L_INCOME | 0.055675** | 9.18E−05** | 0.025603** | 9.29E−05** | 9.22E−06** | 4.51E−06* | 0.008376*** | 0.020213** | 0.001700*** | |
(0.021625) | (3.71E−05) | (0.011596) | (4.08E−05) | (4.45E−06) | (2.32E−06) | (0.001503) | (0.008988) | (0.000620) | ||
INNOV*M_INCOME | 0.015431** | 2.36E−05*** | 0.000147*** | 6.35E−07*** | 1.80E−07** | 4.65E−08*** | 0.004364*** | 0.010358** | 0.001006** | |
(0.006760) | (3.60E−06) | (4.02E−05) | (1.99E−07) | (8.43E−08) | (6.67E−09) | (0.000934) | (0.004720) | (0.000395) | ||
INNOV*H_INCOME | 0.012501*** | 7.48E−06*** | 3.64E−05*** | 1.12E−06*** | 4.01E−07*** | 3.11E−07* | 0.002853*** | 0.011201* | 0.000620** | |
(0.004466) | (1.65E−06) | (1.19E−05) | (4.19E−07) | (1.51E−07) | (1.65E−07) | (0.000885) | (0.006021) | (0.000291) | ||
Obs | 1016 | 482 | 393 | 313 | 701 | 836 | 710 | 366 | 549 | 583 |
Countries | 78 | 53 | 44 | 41 | 72 | 68 | 64 | 53 | 58 | 65 |
Number instruments/number cross-section ratio | 0.782 | 0.962 | 0.977 | 0.951 | 0.847 | 0.868 | 0.797 | 0.811 | 0.793 | 0.738 |
Prob J | 0.160384 | 0.375879 | 0.332168 | 0.258393 | 0.384292 | 0.314723 | 0.301224 | 0.308133 | 0.174854 | 0.336980 |
AR(1) | − 0.420420 | − 0.374270 | − 0.402709 | − 0.398945 | − 0.354249 | − 0.457684 | − 0.439731 | − 0.468025 | − 0.389239 | − 0.352414 |
P-value | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 |
AR(2) | − 0.052266 | − 0.088957 | − 0.103738 | − 0.054130 | − 0.069411 | − 0.042501 | − 0.050278 | 0.019809 | − 0.043591 | − 0.044065 |
P-value | 0.1607 | 0.1135 | 0.1146 | 0.4427 | 0.1386 | 0.1915 | 0.2290 | 0.7711 | 0.4141 | 0.3586 |