The Official Journal of the Pan-Pacific Association of Input-Output Studies (PAPAIOS)
 | Panel v-statistic | Panel rho-statistic | Panel PP-statistic | Panel ADF-statistic | Group rho-statistic | Group PP-statistic | Group ADF-statistic |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Food, beverages, and tobacco | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 0.633522 | 1.186253 | − 11.06104*** | − 9.342591*** | 3.191868 | − 14.42343*** | − 12.47216*** |
 Model 2 | 0.524228 | 3.071354 | − 1.858378** | − 3.083415*** | 3.074340 | − 8.121298*** | − 8.188508*** |
Textile | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 3.260886 | 0.331943 | − 13.47186*** | − 13.51722*** | 3.627371 | − 14.75801*** | − 11.75723*** |
 Model 2 | − 1.268942 | − 0.247425 | − 9.276928*** | − 9.091001*** | 0.936795 | − 12.41171*** | − 10.86444*** |
Pulp and paper | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 1.116840 | 2.353719 | − 5.272305*** | − 5.810947*** | 4.186269 | − 11.65780*** | − 11.00601*** |
 Model 2 | − 2.275577 | 1.352191 | − 5.458742*** | − 6.423706*** | 3.049061 | − 10.56902*** | − 10.60219*** |
Chemical, oil, and coal | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 3.351159 | 1.727338 | − 8.860695*** | − 9.665512*** | 3.502405 | − 12.61057*** | − 10.21496*** |
 Model 2 | 0.810342 | − 0.998458 | − 10.84296*** | − 10.16332*** | 2.123284 | − 12.58159*** | − 11.40520*** |
Ceramic, stone, and clay | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 1.877550 | 2.779795 | − 9.887294*** | − 11.13769*** | 4.744119 | − 15.68208*** | − 14.48236*** |
 Model 2 | − 0.211758 | 1.340087 | − 8.980306*** | − 11.52403*** | 4.450108 | − 9.940711*** | − 13.07724*** |
Iron and steel | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 1.818146 | 3.258006 | − 4.952851*** | − 7.471220*** | 4.731502 | − 9.845332*** | − 9.396072*** |
 Model 2 | − 3.388243 | 0.599767 | − 6.475321*** | − 8.831578*** | 2.740432 | − 8.065791*** | − 9.920696*** |
Machinery | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 3.343544 | 4.425752 | − 2.744002*** | − 4.061561*** | 5.724367 | − 4.840543*** | − 5.351731*** |
 Model 2 | − 2.486851 | 2.123776 | − 3.672093*** | − 5.515955*** | 5.406364 | − 1.050780 | − 3.824743*** |
Manufacturing | |||||||
 Model 1 | − 3.998727 | 1.696246 | − 9.030381*** | − 9.066138*** | 4.470256 | − 14.07822*** | − 11.55655*** |
 Model 2 | − 0.687899 | 0.269362 | − 9.502857*** | − 11.78776*** | 4.996930 | − 3.893301*** | − 7.458334*** |